Though it was never platted, a small community sprung up around the Macedonia post office at what’s now the intersection of East County Road 700-S and South County Road 200-E. A cemetery has existed in the area since 1840, but by 1881, William Suit operated a store there and a Mr. Gross acted as the village’s blacksmith¹. A post office inside the store was discontinued in 1890 and the community subsequently shriveled up². At some point later, the United Brethren Church immediately east of the cemetery was torn down to supply lumber for a grocery store on US-35³.