Tomlinson Cemetery holds more than history for me

Read time: 6 min.

Most of the cemeteries I visit are of the pioneer variety: small, secluded burial grounds where the last interment took place generations ago. I rarely find myself exploring one that’s just that old but still in use, but that’s the case with rural Tomlinson Cemetery southwest of Muncie: established nearly two centuries ago, I found myself there on Saturday under circumstances very different from my typical explorations.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

Monroe Township didn’t have a burial ground when it was established- none of the settlers had died yet! Its first death occurred in 1831, but the body was taken to Rees Cemetery in Perry Township instead1. The first cemetery in Monroe, originally called Christian Friends Church Cemetery but known as Fairview today, was established around 18332. A second on the Mansfield farm was started later that year but never donated to the township for public use3. Tomlinson Cemetery was founded by a Tomlinson and a Huffman4 around 18355. A fourth burial ground serving the village of Macedonia came a little later.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

As of this writing, Tomlinson serves as the final resting place for about 5,200 souls. I think that makes it Delaware County’s fifth-largest cemetery after Beech Grove, Elm Ridge, Gardens of Memory, and Union. A pair of brick gates with stone urns flank the drive heading in. Past those, the most prominent landmark, a mausoleum, was built in 1926 for Lewis Postel and, presumably, his wife Emma. A well-known “realtor” from Columbus, Ohio, Postel died at seventy-one in 19336. Despite his prominence, Postel might have been best known for the lawsuit that occurred after his death.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

I think the paper’s description of Postel as a “realtor” really means he was a landlord. At any rate, his wife, Emma, filed for divorce not long before he passed. She claimed that most of his holdings were acquired during their marriage through the use of her funds. The property was divided, and then Lewis Postel died. Afterwards, Emma declared that he’d concealed $28,000 (a whopping $670,000 today) in bonds and cash from her! She sued his estate but died before things were resolved7. Needless to say, Emma is not buried in her ex-husband’s mausoleum.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

I gather that Tomlinson’s north side is home to its earliest burials. One of the most prominent there marks the grave of John and Nora Driscoll. John Driscoll was a prominent farmer and member of a variety of fraternal organizations who died at about fifty in 19118. Nora followed twenty-three years later. The Driscoll plot is dominated by a massive granite monument with a blank rectangular panel that stands near smaller, offset headstones. This must have been a popular arrangement in 1911- I saw it elsewhere in the cemetery.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

I’m always on the lookout for white bronze monuments- hearty, hollow structures made of a zinc alloy by the Monumental Bronze Company between 1874 and 19149. The metal markers were inexpensive in their day but aged far better than their limestone contemporaries. The only one I spied at Tomlinson honored Elizabeth Fodge, or Elizabeth Fodge McConnell, who died at sixty-two on April 14, 1880.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

Across the way, I noticed a gleaming rectangular monument that almost seemed to shine under the cloudy sky. It commemorates C.R. Martin, who died at sixty-five in 1943. Up close, I realized Martin’s marker shone so because of some kind of coating applied to it; a coating that, unfortunately, was beginning to peel.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

A variety of markers from obelisks, arches, panels, and drums of every age populate the grounds of Tomlinson Cemetery. They’re zinc, limestone, and every color of granite you could imagine. The earliest appears to belong to Lavina H. Perdiue, a resident of Guilford County, North Carolina, who died here in 1838. The most recent at Tomlinson may well be my stepdad Jerry, whose ashes seven of us gathered to inter on Saturday.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

Tomlinson Cemetery wasn’t some ancestral burial ground where generations of Jerry’s family had been laid to rest. Its significance began in 1959, when Jerry’s old brother, Sammy, died suddenly at eleven years old10. Sammy’s death was devastating and left a lasting impression on Jerry, who was only five. When their parents, Junior and Pauline, died, they were buried right next to their oldest son. Jerry’s older sister Nancy eventually joined them, and now Jerry has too. After all these years, Jerry’s reunited with the family he lost along the way- perhaps in more ways than one.

Photo taken November 14, 2026.

I’ve spent years wandering through old cemeteries, reading names on weathered headstones and piecing together the lives of people I never knew. Tomlinson Cemetery was different: instead of coming to explore its history, I came to say goodbye to someone who played a huge part in shaping my own story. The next time I visit, I’ll still stop to admire the monuments and wonder about those who were buried beneath them. I’ll just have another reason to be there -Jerry, who was about as good a guy as ever mustered- and a series of markers that mean something beyond the other dates and names carved into stone.

Sources Cited
1 Helm, T. B. (1881). Mount Pleasant Township. In History of Delaware County, Indiana: With Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Some of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers. Book, Kingman Brothers.
2 Fairview Cemetery (n.d.). Find a Grave. Web. Retrieved November 14, 2026.
3 (See footnote 1).
4 Shannon, S. (2005, November 21). Cemetery has a history of help in times of despair. The Muncie Star Press. p. 4.
5 (See footnote 1).
6 Postel Funeral Rites Tomorrow (1933, June 2). The Muncie Star. p. 18.
7 Order Retrial of Postel Suit (1938, April 29). The Muncie Evening Press. p. 15.
8 John Driscoll Dies (1911, March 10). The Muncie Star. p. 14.
9 Haugh, C. (2019, September 8). White Bronze Markers. Mount Olivet Cemetery [Frederick]. Web. Retrieved June 18, 2025.
10 Eleven-Year-Old Samuel E. Miller Dies at Hospital.

One thought on “Tomlinson Cemetery holds more than history for me”

Leave a Reply