Churubusco is a town about sixteen miles northwest of Fort Wayne along State Road 33. Entering from the south, as I did many times on the way to my dad’s house, there’s an enormous Tudor Revival machine shop, a Subway, a bank, and an IGA grocery. Across from the IGA sits the Magic Wand and its fantastic old sign. In a place dominated by tall-tale turtles, this restaurant takes the cake.

This was accidentally set to go live yesterday. If you’re a subscriber, you probably got an email. Sorry!
The Magic Wand has been a staple of northern Indiana cuisine since Max and Judy Myers opened it in 19641. The place is such an institution that it’s even listed in the Indiana State Historic Architectural and Archaeological Research Database2! Along with his wife, the Myers’ grandson, David Hill, bought the Magic Wand in 20113. Since then, it’s won tons of local awards: among them, Fort Wayne’s Journal Gazette named it one of the area’s finest restaurants in 20164, then named its cobbler one of the area’s best desserts the following year5!

People love the Magic Wand. Judging by the crowd when I last drove past -not to mention those awards- it’s easy to see why! Unfortunately, I didn’t stop. One of my cardinal rules for drives is to sample local fare whenever possible, but that decree comes with an unfortunate corollary: one of my myriad personal failings is my pathological reluctance to stop anywhere that’s busy. Fortunately, I had lunch lined up at my favorite Mexican restaurant in Elkhart that day.

Anyway, I’ve eaten at the Magic Wand before thanks to my dad- just once, about sixteen years ago. Dad had been in bands for most of my life- not cool ones, mind you, but in ensembles like the American Legion and Shrine Bands where he played low brass. When I lived in Fort Wayne, practice brought him down from Elkhart every now and then. If I was working the night shift at Subway, he’d stop in for a sandwich. If I wasn’t, we’d hit up Hall’s Guesthouse or Fish of Stroh. One day, Dad and I met at the Magic Wand.

Fifteen years ago or so, the Magic Wand featured wood-paneled walls practically coated with clown memorabilia like paintings, prints, and plates. I remember ordering the Magic Burger, which was sort of like a Big Mac with a slightly spicier sauce. I either read, or was told by our waitress, that the meat came from the IGA across the highway! My burger was great, and the fries were fine, but Dad pronounced whatever he ordered less magic than tragic. I was suspicious then and remain suspicious now: this review came from a man who often ordered his burgers without cheese so he could “savor the meat-“ from McDonald’s!

Dad died months after our visit, and I never got to roast him about his burger habit. Still, after sixteen years or so, it’s high time for another visit to the Magic Wand. I’ve heard its tenderloin is to die for, but a breaded cheeseburger always strikes my fancy. The place also features Criss Cross Fries which, per Google reviews, look all the world like Spiral Spuds we used to indulge in at Fort Wayne’s Three Rivers Festival.

Stopping there might be strange without Dad across the table being all sardonic, but I think that’s part of the appeal of longstanding landmarks like the Magic Wand. Sometimes, the memories are as good as the food! Next time I’m up in Churubusco, I’ll brave the crowd and try to conjure up a little more magic of my own.
Sources Cited1 Duvall, R. (2017, September 17). Churubusco diner is not clownng around. The Fort Wayne Journal Gazette. Web. Retrieved November 19, 2026.
2 Survey Number 183-111-01047 (2001). IHSSI (County Survey). SHAARD. Indiana Department of Natural Resources [Indianapolis]. Web. Retrieved November 19, 2026.
3 Sade, V. (2015, August 18). Chamber Names Magic Wand Business of the Month. Churubusco News. Web. Retrieved November 19, 2026.
4 Decade of decadence (2016, March 16). The Fort Wayne Journal Gazette. Web. Retrieved November 19, 2026.
5 Dining Out: Best of 2017 (2017, December 31). The Fort Wayne Journal Gazette. Web. Retrieved November 19, 2026.

I love places like this, and like you I hate to visit them when they’re busy. Hopefully the sign’s still in good working order!
It worked last time I drove by at night! That was a few years ago.
Ooh, I love the look of this place! You need to go back for a culinary refresher.
I do! Next time I head up to Elkhart, I’ll be there!