Anderson Township’s District 5 school received its common name, Baker Hill, due to its location at the apex of a highland near the modern-day terminus of Gun Barn Road at Moss Island Road1.
The extant school, one of Madison County’s few remaining frame schoolhouses, closed some time prior to 1883, when the services of Bailey Chapel Church -theretofore held in the old Moss Island schoolhouse- moved in. In 1895, a purpose-built church was erected nearby2.
After the congregation left, the old District 5 school was developed into a home3. It has been renovated and expanded.
A later consolidated schoolhouse that took students from the old Baker Hill and Moss Island schools was erected south of the extant building in the 1880s. It no longer stands4.
1 Davis, R. (1971, October 28). ‘Stink factory’ not far from Baker Hill School. The Anderson Daily Bulletin. p. 4.
2 Bailey Chapel Will Hold Dedicatory Rites Sunday (1954, September 8). The Anderson Daily Bulletin. p. 14.
3 Jackson, S. T. (2021, December 30). Madison County schoolhouses. email.
4 (See footnote 3).